It really boils down to how much jetlag bothers you. After an overnight to Europe I usually have slight issues right after lunch for a couple of days - kind of "20 minute snooze" issues - and I go to bed a few hours later at night, not too much, so it's a non-issue for me. OTOH put me on a day flight, especially in a nice seat where I might doze off and generally relax and I'll get off a plane ready to be up all night - and I'm not a DJ in my line of work, so that's not all that helpful.
So I'm a night flight person too, to the point that I'll even do red eyes to BOS or NY now over the day flights, and they are around 1000 miles shorter. I just seem to do OK on the other end even with 3 or 4 hours sleep, and I don't lose a whole day in the process.