Originally posted by mas66
Hi Will
I have already posted to this thread however......
Without seeming rude your list reads like something from sites that offer ill informed advice on how to get an upgade.
I can say with great confidence that your point 3 is wrong. Frequent flyer status does have a bearing on upgrades for both BA and VS. Im not saying it makes things a certainty but does have a bearing.
I can also say shes wrong about point 6. I can tell you that from first hand experience. I never travel smart, I travel dressed for comfort for a long haul flight and have been upgraded an several occasions (due to my FC status;))
Im not really sure what is being implied about passengers travelling to the destinations in your last comment, but upgrades are a lot of the time done for operational reasons often to shift passengers from overbooked cabins (of course for many other reasons as well), im sure this would apply to these routes as well.
Firstly appreciate your comments Mark, will now try to answer some of them.
My list wasn't taken from any other site. It was a conversation we had yesterday morning as we were discussing our forthcoming trip together. I put it into bullet form as it made it easier for me to discuss them (sorry being a lawyer we like our lists ;-)) Perhaps my list format did not make what I was saying too clear, sorry.
I certainly did not take the list from an "ill informed website" and would like to think that someone who has had two and a half years experience at BA on check in and now in another department is fairly well informed on what her and her immediate friends in the company do re upgrades.
These are my friends views on the matter and the way she operates. It will of course be different for each person.
Re Point Three: She said that to her FC status doesn't matter- it is up to each check in person who gets upgraded and she prefers to offer an upgrade to an elderly couple on a trip of a lifetime or someone who has been particularly pleasant at check in. Sure she does upgrade Exec club members but there is no hard and fast rule, as far as she is concerned, that if its a choice between two people the exec club member has to be given the upgrade. After all not all FC members are all pleasant and nice like us lot on here. Of course it helps but it doesn't mean its granted. Things could well be different at VS and also across the way in T1.
Point Six- is her own personal preference. She said someone who rocks up looking scruffy- note not casual- they wont get the green light from her.
Re families: my use of the word never in caps was probably a bit too strong. She said in her time there she has only ever upgraded one family.
My last comment was not directed at the people flying on those routes (after all the regulars on here know the MCO and TPA routes are the only ones I fly LH). It was just her observations after 2 and half years work there- the flights are always either full or there aren't enough spare seats to allow for a whole family upgrade.
I agree with HF- there is no rule on it. That is my friends personal opinion on the matter- I just felt given the OP it would be useful to have some insider info even if second hand.
