I thought I'd update you all on progress with 'im indoors. He had been primed with the thought of using the PE upgrade vouchers from Amex, but hadn't really taken it in.
The first reaction to visiting NYC was rejected for a couple of reasons. One being money, he worries about what we can and can't afford and of appearances if we take yet another holiday.

The second reason was an objection to turning right. "If I can't go UC I'm not going" or similar words were used. I tried to sell the PE product to no avail, and the fact that we need to use the vouchers and an east coast flight is ideal for them.
Today we discussed it more and he was more open to it. I suggested maybe Christmas which was appealing (he likes to escape obligatory festive cheer at this time of year and is what many would call humbug!). Then January was mooted, but then he suggested later next year as one of next year's holidays, whereas I'm just looking at a short break. I have since shown him the pictures on VS website of PE cabin and seats, this has resulted in "I could do that" with the recognition he's not back in Y, or cattle class, his words not mine.
I'm going to leave a while now and then see if I can tempt him with Christmas once I've done some sums to counteract his objections to the cost.
Thanks all for your useful ideas and especially Whiterose for emailing me photos which will be used on my next round. This is how I have to work on him, as he's always shied away from holidays until the last few years, and the resistance is strong. I just adopt the old Borg saying, "resistance is futile" and keep wearing him down. Eventually he'll concede to shut me up
